Your current location:HOME >health >US Supreme Court Skeptical of Curbing Government Contact With Social Media Firms 正文
TIME:2024-05-21 09:28:17 Source: Internet compilationEdit:health
Washington —A majority of justices on the U.S. Supreme Court appeared skeptical on Monday of efforts
A majority of justices on the U.S. Supreme Court appeared skeptical on Monday of efforts to impose restrictions on federal government efforts to curb misinformation online.
Both conservative and liberal justices on the nine-member court appeared reluctant to endorse a lower court's ruling that would severely limit government interactions with social media companies.
The case stems from a lawsuit brought by the Republican attorneys general of Louisiana and Missouri, who allege that government officials went too far in their bid to get platforms to combat vaccine and election misinformation, violating the First Amendment free speech rights of users.
The lower court restricted top officials and agencies of Democratic President Joe Biden's administration from meeting and communicating with social media companies to moderate their content.
The ruling, which the Supreme Court put on hold until it heard the case, was a win for conservative advocates who allege that the government pressured or colluded with platforms such as Facebook and X, formerly Twitter, to censor right-leaning content under the guise of fighting misinformation.
Representing the Justice Department in the Supreme Court on Monday, Principal Deputy Solicitor General Brian Fletcher said there is a "fundamental distinction between persuasion and coercion."
"The government may not use coercive threats to suppress speech, but it is entitled to speak for itself by informing, persuading or criticizing private speakers," he said.
The lower court, Fletcher said, "mistook persuasion for coercion."
Justice Samuel Alito, a conservative, said the record showed that government officials had engaged in "constant pestering of Facebook and some of the other platforms," treating them "like their subordinates."
"I cannot imagine federal officials taking that approach to the print media," Alito said.
But Chief Justice John Roberts, also a conservative, said the federal government does not speak with one voice.
"The government is not monolithic," Roberts said. "That has to dilute the concept of coercion significantly, doesn't it?"
Fletcher said interactions between health officials and social media platforms at the heart of the case needed to be viewed in light of "an effort to get Americans vaccinated during a once-in-a-lifetime pandemic."
"There was a concern that Americans were getting their news about the vaccine from these platforms and the platforms were promoting bad information," Fletcher said, adding that "the platforms were moderating content long before the government was talking to them."
'No place in our democracy'
J. Benjamin Aguinaga, the solicitor general of Louisiana, denounced what he called "government censorship," saying it has "no place in our democracy."
"The government has no right to persuade platforms to violate Americans' constitutional rights, and pressuring platforms in backrooms shielded from public view is not using the bully pulpit at all," Aguinaga said. "That's just being a bully."
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, a liberal, pushed back, saying "my biggest concern is that your view has the First Amendment hamstringing the government in significant ways."
"Some might say that the government actually has a duty to take steps to protect the citizens of this country." she said.
Justice Brett Kavanaugh, a conservative, asked whether it would be coercion if someone in government calls up a social media company to point out something that is "factually erroneous information."
The lower court order applied to the White House and a slew of agencies such as the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the State Department, the Justice Department as well as the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
The decision of the lower court restricted agencies and officials from meeting with social media companies or flagging posts.
Louisiana Attorney General Jeff Landry hailed the lower court’s "historic injunction" at the time, saying it would prevent the Biden administration from “censoring the core political speech of ordinary Americans" on social media.
He accused federal officials of seeking to “dictate what Americans can and cannot say on Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, and other platforms about COVID-19, elections, criticism of the government and more."
Some experts in misinformation and First Amendment law criticized the lower court ruling, saying that authorities needed to strike a balance between calling out falsehoods and veering toward censorship or curbing free speech.
The fightback begins: Boss of London's Queen Mary University tells pro2024-05-21 09:23
Madonna shares epic 'memories' from Celebration tour2024-05-21 08:51
Abbey Clancy flaunts her jaw2024-05-21 08:32
Japanese automaker Nissan reports 92% jump in profit as sales surge2024-05-21 08:18
US overdose deaths dropped in 2023, the first time since 20182024-05-21 08:08
Vatican and Rome enter final dash to 2025 Jubilee with papal bull and around2024-05-21 07:34
Rays starting pitcher Ryan Pepiot placed on 152024-05-21 07:19
What will Utah's NHL team be called? Here are 20 options2024-05-21 07:01
Elon Musk gets approval from FDA to implant his Neuralink brain chip into a second patient2024-05-21 06:54
Turnbull scores twice as Toronto cruises past Minnesota 42024-05-21 06:41
A warrant for Netanyahu’s arrest was requested. But no decision was made about whether to issue it2024-05-21 09:14
China's exports and imports return to growth in April as demand improves2024-05-21 09:14
Europeans want governments to focus more on curbing migration than climate change, a study says2024-05-21 08:47
Gogglebox legend signs up for Celebs Go Dating after shock divorce announcement2024-05-21 08:41
Uber and Lyft say they'll stay in Minnesota after Legislature passes driver pay compromise2024-05-21 08:34
China's exports and imports return to growth in April as demand improves2024-05-21 08:30
Gerard Butler transforms back into the rugged hero as Hampshire is turned into apocalypse2024-05-21 08:15
Stock market today: Global shares mixed after Wall Street's lull stretches to a 2nd day2024-05-21 08:02
Jessica Biel CHOPS her long locks into a bob after book signing in Studio City2024-05-21 07:06
Death toll rises to 56 from southern Brazil's heavy rains2024-05-21 06:47